Svein is a regular contributor to Modern Times Review.

The UN climate summits show a world where the nuances between should, must and will, can prove decisive for the outcome of negotiations.

Guardians of the Earth

Filip Antoni Malinowski

Austria, Germany, 2017 86 min


In 1989 Bill McKibben published The End of Nature, and with it a powerful message to the effect that humanity’s destructive impact on the earth’s biosphere was about to reach a point of no return. The mechanisms of climate change that were about to set in would change both nature and our conditions for life forever.

For at least 30 years we’ve known what we’re up against, a fact most people who’ll take the time to watch the documentary Guardians of the Earth know all too well. The film starts by showing Donald Trump responding to a journalist’s question concerning what he’ll do about climate change. Rather than answer, Trump goes on to attack his predecessor. Obama’s statement that global warming poses the most serious problem of our time is, Trump says, the most stupid claim that has ever been made.

Time Is Running Out

We should be grateful that the world doesn’t pay much attention to Trump on this question. The systematic process that for the past three decades has tried to implement more effective climate measures internationally is still moving forward, and much seems to indicate that it’s become a self-reinforcing mechanism. Here many would argue that the process is far too slow, but nevertheless this development is proof of a widely held determination to do something constructive about climate change. The arena where this resolve is put to the test is the UN’s annual climate summit.

«It’s usually in personal conversations – “informal meetings” – that real progress towards good solutions is made.»

After many years of disappointing results, the Paris talks in the autumn of 2015 led to an important breakthrough. Guardians of the Earth provides an interesting look at the teeming anthill of people who met in the French capital. Through a mix of short interviews and footage of the long series of meetings and negotiations, we follow an occasionally powerful engagement. It’s stated as a matter of fact that climate change is happening and that we’re running out of time. It’s similarly highlighted that the goal of keeping the global rise of temperatures to below 2 degrees Celsius isn’t enough. The world will have to achieve 1.5 degrees, above all because of the world’s poor.

An International Framework

There’s a line running from these annual climate summits back to the Brundtland Commission’s Our Common Future of 1987. The report was written as part of a drawn-out process that contributed to bolstering a pragmatic, reform-oriented environmental policy in which it was genuinely believed that technological progress and economic profit should be the basis for saving the environment. The ideal became to locate the problem-solving process in bureaucracy, science, the economy and in self-perpetuating technological progress.

Guardians of the Earth Director: Filip Antoni Malinowski

An international framework, containing everything from common objectives to measures aimed at diverting the economy into a more climate-friendly direction, was eventually put into place. The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change was signed in 1992, and the UN’s annual climate summit has since played a crucial role in securing progress in the field. Over time, its measures have contributed to developing a climate regime that encompasses not only commitments to reducing emissions, but also incorporates institutional arrangements responsible for ensuring that climate adaptations, financial arrangements, the transfer of technology and market-based mechanisms can function properly.

«It’s usually in personal conversations – “informal meetings” – that real progress towards good solutions is made.»

Paradoxical Discourse

Login or signup to read the rest..

If you do not have subscription, you can just login or register, and choose free guest or subscription to read all articles.




Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here