Former Pakistani Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto carved out a complex path, from her early days studying at Berkeley in the late ‘60s, where she honed her social activism, to witnessing the controversial downfall and assassination of her father, former Prime Minister Zulfikar Bhutto, to her house arrest and political imprisonment. Elected as the first female leader of an Islamic nation, she championed a democratic and educated Pakistan through key moments in the country’s turbulent history. Bhutto’s successes and failures were scrutinized by the public, the Islamic world, and within her family.

THE FILM BHUTTO is only to a certain extent about Benazir Bhutto, the first female Prime Minister of Pakistan. The film is really a history of Pakistan. But then, the history of Pakistan coincides with the life of Bhutto. She was born in 1953, only six years after the foundation of Pakistan under British rule in 1947 and only three years before it became an independent country under her father’s rule in 1956. Moreover, what seems to have been one of Pakistan’s central issues, the collision between modernism and traditionalism, also seems to have been central to Bhutto herself.

Raised in a feudal, progressive family, she was educated at top Western universities in the seventies, a time of burgeoning emancipation and anti-military protests. She was an advocate of equal rights and opened a women’s police station to underline this. But she was not a feminist. While Thatcher, Ghandi and Meir are known for their male strength, she saw the nurturing nature of women as an important contribution and asset. She married because she felt it necessary for her work as Prime Minister. She is presented as a devout Muslim. She performed the Umrah, a religious pilgrimage including rituals, for her father. Her scarf was always half-heartedly halfway covering her head. Towards the end, she put her life in God’s hands: “I am unaware of the details of the security arrangements but I think the biggest protection comes from God. And God willing, all will go well” she says just before her return to Pakistan in October 2007.

“Bhutto” 2010 directed by Duane Baughman and Johnny O’Hara

THE DICHOTOMY between modernism and traditionalism has characterised Pakistan for a long time. According to Aziz Talbani, Islam was – through the so-called Objective Resolution and the Principles of State Policy (a kind of constitution) – a legitimate part of Pakistan’s political discourse. 1)Aziz Talbani, Pedagody, power, and discourse: Transformation of Islamic Education. Comparative Education Review, Feb. 1996, p. 66-82.  At the same time, the first rulers of the independent republic were modern, educated in the West, with more Western and liberal values than those of traditional Islam. The military has always been just as much a part of Pakistan politics as civilian politicians. Pakistan not only had to free itself from British rule, it also struggled for East Pakistan – now Bangladesh – and the struggle over Kashmir continues today. Failing to create economic welfare for the people, the western-style Bhutto sr. dynasty was overthrown by general Zia-ul-Hacq. He allied with the fundamentalists. After her father’s execution, Bhutto spent the rest of her life fighting the military, with democracy as remedy. In the film, the first thing she says after her election is: “I have avenged my father today”. It seems she lost herself in a never-ending battle for power.

Login or signup to read the rest..

If you do not have subscription, you can just login or register, and choose free guest or subscription to read all articles.



References   [ + ]

1. Aziz Talbani, Pedagody, power, and discourse: Transformation of Islamic Education. Comparative Education Review, Feb. 1996, p. 66-82.