Choices of war

    CONFLICT: Sergei Loznitsa’s sombre documentary, The Natural History of Destruction, re-examines the heavy bombing of British and German cities during World War Two, posing the question – ‘is it morally acceptable to kill civilian populations as a means of war?’

    Berlin-based, Belarussian-born Ukrainian citizen Sergei Loznitsa has long been a controversial figure on the European art-house scene.

    A native Russian speaker, Loznitsa was born in Baranovichi in Belarus but grew up in Kyiv and is firmly opposed to the Russian war of aggression currently raging in his homeland.

    That has not prevented him from becoming a divisive figure among those filmmakers and artists who see him as morally compromised by a position on the war that opposes the orthodoxy that all Russian film and culture should be banned from European arts venues during the current conflict.

    The Natural History of Destruction, a film by Sergei Loznitsa
    The Natural History of Destruction, a film by Sergei Loznitsa


    That Loznitsa is anti-war is indisputable: much of his filmography – features and documentaries – has been intimately involved with dissecting the long fall-out from World War Two and more contemporary issues of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine, going back at least as far as the «Maidan» revolution in Ukraine in 2013/2014 and Moscow’s subsequent annexation of Crimea, and support from secessionist rebels in the Donbas.

    That his position on culture is more nuanced than many of his compatriots – with notable Ukrainian film producers and industry professionals castigating him for opposing cancel culture on Russia, or even for public comments at the Cannes Film Festival where he failed to talk about Ukrainian culture – is clear.

    In the early days following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine on February 24, Loznitsa resigned from the European Film Academy over the weak and muted language it used to condemn the Russian invasion.

    A statement by the EFA noting «the invasion in Ukraine is heavily worrying us» was slammed as «shameful» by Loznitsa, who noted in an open letter, «the Russian army has been devastating Ukrainian cities and villages, killing Ukrainian citizens. Is it really possible that you – humanists, human rights and dignity advocates, champions of freedom and democracy, are afraid to call a war a war, to condemn barbarity and voice your protest?»

    However, his openness towards shielding Russian culture and individual film directors from boycott got him into trouble with Ukrainian compatriots. He was subsequently dismissed from the Ukrainian Film Academy in a move Loznitsa described as «a gift to Russian propagandists.»

    The world premiere of Loznitsa’s latest film – The Natural History of Destruction – took place May 23 against a backdrop of the glitz, glamour – and political controversy of the 75th edition of the Cannes Film Festival.

    That has not prevented him from becoming a divisive figure among those filmmakers and artists who see him as morally compromised by a position on the war…

    Cannes controversy

    The inclusion in the main programme of Russian director Kirill Serebrennikov’s Tchaikovsky’s Wife had attracted widespread criticism – not helped by Serebrennikov using a Cannes press conference to defend its funder, sanctioned Russian oligarch, Roman Abramovich, and to express his sorrow for the families of Russian soldiers sent to fight in Ukraine. Coming as the world reels at mounting evidence of Russian war crimes and the indisputable evidence of the rape, torture, and execution of Ukrainian civilians revealed in Bucha, Irpin, and elsewhere in the war zone, Serebrennikov’s comments piled the pressure on festival president Thierry Frémaux, whose tin-ear to concerns over his controversial decision to include the film dominated many conversations at Cannes this year.

    The festival’s opening film (Michael Hazanavicius’ Coupez!) had also aroused rage from Ukrainians as the odd-ball zombie horror had initially been called Z (comme Z) – seen by many as unwittingly supporting Russian aggression, as the letter Z had been adopted as a propaganda symbol in Russia due to its extensive use as an army group call-sign painted on invading tanks and armoured vehicles.

    The Natural History of Destruction is a lengthy (nearly two hours) documentary of the mutually destructive heavy bombing of civilian populations in British and German cities during the 1940s – dropped into this typically Cannes artistic melee with the force of a 500-kilo air drop bomb.

    The Natural History of Destruction, a film by Sergei Loznitsa
    The Natural History of Destruction, a film by Sergei Loznitsa

    Based on

    Based on the eponymous 1999 book by German W.G. Sebald, the film opens with a montage of bucolic pre-war German scenes, cityscapes of fine Medieval buildings, and ordinary, industrious Germans . . .

    Dear reader. To continue reading, please create your free account with your email,
    or login if you have registered already. (click forgotten password, if not in an email from us).
    A subscription is only 9€ 🙂

    What about a subscription, for full access and 2-3 print copies in your mail a year?
    (Modern Times Review is a non-profit organisation, and really appreciate such support from our readers.) 

    Nick Holdsworth
    Our regular critic. Journalist, writer, author. Works mostly from Central and Eastern Europe and Russia.
    26th Ji.hlava IDFF unveils 2022 visual identity, early programme highlightsThe 2022 Ji.hlava IDFF has announced the first programme highlight of this year’s edition - the latest film by...
    DocuDays UA brings National Competition films, works-in-progress, more across Sheffield Doc/Fest activitiesIn solidarity with Ukraine, Sheffield DocFest's «Password: Palianytsia» is a collaborative doc programme with #Docudays UA#.The programme with DocuDays...
    Chile continues worldwide documentary circuit with Sheffield Doc/Fest official selectionsFollowing a successful Sunny Side of the Doc, Sheffield Doc/Fest’s 29th edition will also feature a considerable Chilean presence.Breaking...
    NEOLIBERALISM: Breaking the Brick (dir: Carola Fuentes, …)Breaking The Brick plucks us into the heat of Chile's social unrest, reliving the Chicago Boys' contentious legacy.
    UKRAINE: One Day in Ukraine (dir: Volodymyr Tykhyy)A glimpse of the war as experienced by Ukrainians every day since Russian forces invaded on February 24, 2022.
    DOCS: Subject (dir: Jennifer Tiexiera, …)Some of the biggest non-fiction films of the past years go under the microscope, investigating the ethics of documenting trauma.
    ISRAEL: H2: The Occupation Lab (dir: Idit Avrahami, …)The story of the eastern side of Hebron, a microcosm of a conflict and a test site for control throughout the West Bank.
    ABUSE: Look What You Made Me Do (dir: Coco Schrijber)Three survivors of domestic violence who have murdered their abusers are given a chance to tell their stories.
    POLITICS: My Imaginary Country (dir: Patricio Guzmán)At Cannes, Patrizio Guzmán´s documentary offers one of the rare elements of hope in global politics.
    - Advertisement -

    You might also likeRELATED
    Recommended to you