The whole process of making the film is a story of carefully selecting and closely examining the images to discover new details and incorporating them into the film in the right way. DOX met her and her producer-husband Ansgar Schäfer at Docs Kingdom (see page 15).
“Still Life” (reviewed in DOX#60) is a personal interpretation of the dictatorship in Portugal, like a collection of memories from the period. Susana de Sousa Dias takes up the challenge of showing the reality of the oppressed by using images shot by the oppressors. The 72-minute film has only twelve minutes of archive footage (mostly propaganda) and police photographs of political prisoners, with no words, but an originally composed music score. The archive footage is shown in slow-motion, shots are repeated and other sequences zoom in on details and faces in the images. The scenes are divided by fading into and out of black.
“This film is about a period of Portuguese history but you say it is not a historical film, so what is it?”
Susana: When I said that, I meant a ‘historical film’ in the traditional sense. I wanted to make a film dealing with historical material, but I didn’t want to explain history. I didn’t want to come up with a speech about history. I didn’t want to work with words, only images. In the Doc’s Kingdom debate, we were discussing ways of approaching a subject; there is always a dilemma: either you know or you see. If you know, you move inside a stable world but you lose the real image; if you see without knowing, you lose the stability and find yourself in an uncomfortably open world. From the beginning, I sought to move in the field of ‘to see’. It is the image that opens up themes, the issues I seek to deal with. We see the images without any pressure from the words, without that violence of the speech that commands how we read what we see.
For me, it was not very important that this story happened in Portugal-yet it happened in Portugal and of course I share that history- but I wanted to raise questions to encourage reflection on our present. The way we see a picture today depends both on memory and on the present because an image is never a fixed point in the course of history. Every image is caught in the movement from past to future. There is no crystallised time. What I also sought to achieve with this film was reverberation across different peoples, different ages, different countries.
“Are you allowed to use archive material in this way: taking it out of the context it was made for and manipulating it like you do, using slow motion and inserting it into another context?”
Susana: I think yes, one can do this, but it depends on the approach. I have my own ethical attitude as to the images. Right from the start, I established my limits. I have always tried to use the images without subverting them. My intention was never to take them out of their original context. There have been times when people have asked me why didn’t I edit them in a different way, that is, far more concentrated, with far greater emotional impact. I simply couldn’t do that. However, perhaps the greatest question I had to deal with was how could I show the reverse side of the dictatorship through the very images produced by that dictatorship. This proved really difficult, but it was also a challenge.
Ansgar: If you look at the material we use, it is propaganda, but well-produced propaganda. That is why it is so very easy to actually believe the message behind these images. The aim of propaganda is not to show reality but rather what any regime wants its people to believe in. So, the problem was how to show the reality of a dictatorial regime where there is no critical material-the opposition had no means to film, and even if they had, it would probably have been destroyed. So you have to find this counter-image within the propaganda material and this was the particular problem here.
“I do think some of the images get the opposite meaning with just being shown like you do, like those from the former colonies, for example, with the soldiers and the boys playing the drums-I don’t know which country it was from.”
Login or signup to read the rest..If you do not have subscription, you can just login or register, and choose free guest or subscription to read all articles.