Young is a regular contributor to Modern Times Review.

Two of the most distinctive and notable of the premieres at Rotterdam, concerned Ukraine. One xx and the other urban to its very core.


Size isn’t everything. At the time of writing the Ukraininian super-featherweight Vasyl Lomachenko, all 60kg and 166cm of him, is considered one of the world’s two or three greatest active boxers. As in pugilism, so in cinema. Like Lomachenko, short films at their best strike quick and hard, punch far above their weight, and are often, “pound-for-pound” more rewarding and satisfying than films of conventional feature-length. This is especially true of experimenta, and also of non-fiction.

Any survey of European documentary cinema in the last couple of years which overlooks such outstanding examples as Gabriel Abrantes’ A Brief History of Princess X (2016, 7m), Arthur Summereder’s The French Road: Detroit MI (2015, 7m), Mehdi Ahoudig & Anna Salzberg’s We’ll Go to Neuilly, Inshallah (2015, 19m), Lawrence Abu Hamdan’s Rubber Coated Steel (2017, 21m), Aline Magrez’s No’i (2016, 21m), Isabel Pagliai’s Isabella Morra (2015m 22m), and Igor Bezinović’s Veruda: A Film About Bojan (2015, 34m) – to name just a handful – is operating on a one-eyed basis.

«Short documentaries has a capacity to dazzle and delight.»

The capacity of short documentaries to dazzle and delight was amply illustrated by the 47th International Film Festival Rotterdam (IFFR), which ran from January 24 to February 4 in the vibrantly multicultural Dutch mega-port. One of the venerable (but still edgy) behemoths of the film-festival circuit – with around 300,000 “visits” annually to its screenings, exhibitions and side-happenings – IFFR is really five or six different simultaneous interlocking events at once, some of which are only tangentially connected with cinema as it is traditionally perceived.

This can be a strength and a weakness – in terms of feature-length work Rotterdam struggles to compete with Amsterdam’s IDFA (for longer documentaries) and Berlin (for fiction). But on certain fronts IFFR reliably excels. Its shorts programmes are invariably numerous and well-curated: this year 22 titles competed for three equally prestigious ‘Tiger’ prizes – out of a total of 264 short/mid-length films screened in total, including 80 world premieres.


By happy coincidence, two of the most distinctive and notable of those premieres concerned Lomachenko’s homeland –  where a somewhat “forgotten” war with Russia continues to take and ruin lives on a weekly basis, even if it seems to have dropped off the global journalistic radar. These films present Ukraine in original, illuminating and very personal ways which conventionally objective, TV-oriented journalistic/reportage documentaries cannot easily attempt – and were made by artists previously best known for their still photography.

«The wide range of opinions held in Ukraine about Lenin and what he represents.»

In almost every other regard, however, Tobias Zielony’s Maskirovka and Anna Jermolaewa’s Leninopad could scarcely be more different, either in terms of form or content. Rather unfairly passed over by the Tiger jury (for this writer, it was more deserving than any of the three eventual laureates) Maskirovka is provocative, audacious and jolting. It comprises nine blunt minutes of rapidly alternating images – the film has been described by more than one source as an “animation” – unfolding in total silence, with neither opening nor closing titles. Assaultive and uncompromising in the starkness of its purpose – to plunge us into the milieu of hedonistic Kiev youth against a backdrop of political turmoil – the film is a concentrated burst of imagery and energy whose brisk duration is part of its appeal and its charm.

Tobias Zielony

A first-person travelogue essay

“Short” films, usually made with little or no concession to commercial considerations, have the great benefit over their longer cousins that they are precisely as leisurely or as brief as they need to be; if an artist wants to express herself in a three-second gif or in a 45-minute “sprawl,” the format allows her to do so. Budgets are generally low, sometimes sub-shoestring; shooting and editing schedules can be economically rapid, benefiting from quick turnarounds – whereas feature-length documentaries often get bogged down in complex, protracted funding negotiations and post-production complications.

You have to login or create account (top menu) to read on for a while. Or get full access, print magazines and your own presentation page as a member.

Facebook Comments